b-di.com Understanding Behavioral Individuality
Home Parents Students Researchers Clinicians Resources
Temperament differences in children
How behavioral style matters
Basic Information
Temperament & Behavioral Individuality
Quick Links

Origins
Concepts
Measurement
Stability

and more. See below...
  For Students
   Places to Go
What's New? Things to do FAQs Discover your temperament? Kate's Newsletter B-DI Catalog Providers Temperament Consortium Listserv
   Adult temperament
health New Version!
Learn about your true self.
Take the Adult Temperament Questionnaire
   CBAM2: 2016 Edition
health Free! PDF Download
For Primary Care Professionals
Normal Misbehavior
   Things to do at this site
Things to do at this site
More..  
 Measuring Temperament

How do we know what a person's
temperament really is?

Methods for measuring temperament


There are a number of different schemes for conceptualizing temperamental characteristics (see the dimensions of temperament link for more on this). But no matter how the various traits are defined, there needs to be a way for researchers and/or clinicians to take 'measurements' in a group of individuals.

Three ways appear to be most common: interviews, observations and questionnaires. Of course, there are many different procedures used with each method but data gathering in the temperament field is most likely to utilize one of these techniques.

Interviews usually involve asking a series of standardized questions to each person in the group being evaluated and recording the answers, which are later rated based on a rubric devised for that purpose. The original NYLS research used a 'semi-structured' interview method where parent's statements about their infants were elicited and then rated as high, intermediate or low for each of the nine temperament characteristics. Advantages for the interview method include being able to ask followup questions to more accurately determine the response and having the respondent present to allow for inclusion of nonverbal information such as tone of voice, body posture and attitude in the assessment, as clincians frequently do. Disadvantages incude the cost of doing lengthy session 1:1 with subjects, and the cost of having an interviewer spend an extended amount of time with each individual.

Observations used in research involve looking directly the individual's temperament-related behavior, either in their own setting (such as home or school) or in a structured environment such as a laboratory. In addition, clinicians may do direct observations in their offices. Observations may be rated using a coding system to score temperament dimensions while the behavior is being carried out, or the behavior may be videotaped and coded later. Advantages of observational methods include the presence of an 'objective observer' who is able to use a standard format to record what is seen. Disadvantages include the brevity of observational sessions (typically 20 minutes to one hour on a single day) and the limitation of the observation to one or a small number of settings, potentially limiting the reliability of the measure.

Questionnaires are also employed to assess temperament; ratings can be obtained from parents and other caregivers, teachers, child care workers, or even from the person themselves. The ratings typically require a numerical response to a standardized question asscociated with a temperament characteristic. Anywhere from 5 to 15 items per scale are typical. Questionnaire ratings are usually normed upon a large sample and individual profiles are compared with the established norms. The advantages of questionnaires are that items are standardized, they are completed within a few minutes and are a relatively inexpensive way to collect data. Disadvantages include potential rater bias or distortion, inability to clarify ambiguous or incomplete responses and need to establish validity of ratings.

Studies have looked at the overlap between different measures of temperament when assessing the same subjects and typically find low to moderate correlations between different measures, indicating significant overlap but also specific contributions according to method of measurement. Most clinicians and researchers use multimethod assessments as a result.
 
Home  |  Parents  |  Students  |  Researchers  |  Clinicians  |  Resources
   Key Issues:
 
Biological basis
Temperament Heritability
Behavioral genetics has established that temperament is at least partially genetic...
Traits can be similar in families
and also similar for individuals with genetic similarities...
More>>
 
Measuring temperament
How do we know?

There are several ways to assess temperament, including interview, direct observation and questionnaires.
Each method has advantages
and disadvantages, depending on the questions being asked...
More>>
 
How stable?
Stability and change
are key elements of temperament across the life span.
A number of studies have looked at
whether temperament stays constant over time...
More>>
 
Dimensions of temperament
There are several alternative schemes
for conceptualizing temperament
variables that lead to differences in concepts and the gathering of evidence to support them.
More>>